Ecommerce Payment Gateways: How to Choose One (2026)

Short answer: for most small US stores, use the payment processor built into your platform. Shopify Payments, Square, Wix Payments, Squarespace Payments, BigCommerce Payments and WooPayments all start at about the same card rate, and the built-in option avoids the extra fee some platforms add when you bring your own provider. The exceptions: Shopify adds 2%, 1% or 0.6% on top when you use an outside provider and doesn't let you add Stripe at all in the US, while BigCommerce lets you use your own Stripe account with no platform fee. PayPal costs more per sale than a card but many shoppers want it. All prices here are US pricing.

Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you buy through one, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. How this works.

On this page
  1. What a gateway does
  2. Built-in processors and their rates
  3. Stripe
  4. PayPal
  5. Shopify’s outside-provider fee
  6. BigCommerce’s embedded providers
  7. Chargebacks and disputes
  8. When the money arrives
  9. Card data and PCI
  10. How to choose
  11. Common mistakes
  12. Where this fits
  13. How we put this together

Where this comes from. Rates come from our data files (platform help centres, WooCommerce’s WooPayments page and PayPal’s US business fee page), checked on November 21, 2026. Stripe’s and PayPal’s fee pages change with the visitor’s country, so their figures are US readings that we flag for a recheck. Payout and dispute wording comes from each vendor’s help pages. We may earn a commission if you sign up for Shopify through our links. This is general information, not financial advice.

What a gateway does

When a shopper pays, the checkout sends the card details to a payment provider for approval, and the provider later pays the money to your bank account, minus its fee. For a small store the choice is usually between:

  • The processor built into your platform, set up from the store settings. This is the default on every hosted platform.
  • An outside provider such as Stripe or PayPal, which you connect to the platform.

Built-in processors and their rates

Platform Built-in processor Online card rate (US) Fee for using an outside provider
Shopify Shopify Payments 2.9% + 30¢ on Basic, 2.7% + 30¢ on Grow, 2.5% + 30¢ on Advanced 2%, 1% or 0.6% on top of the provider’s own fees; PayPal exempt
Square Online Square 3.3% + 30¢ on Free, 2.9% + 30¢ on Plus and Premium Not stated; Square processes payments
Wix Wix Payments 2.9% + 30¢ on every plan Wix lists no fee on other providers
Squarespace Squarespace Payments 2.9% + 30¢ on Core, 2.7% + 30¢ on Plus, 2.5% + 30¢ on Advanced 2% of each sale on Basic; none from Core
BigCommerce BigCommerce Payments (powered by PayPal) 2.89% + 30¢ on Core, 2.59% + 30¢ on Growth, 2.39% + 30¢ on Scale None with embedded providers; a fee on other providers
WooCommerce WooPayments 2.9% + 30¢ None

US rates, checked November 21, 2026. Higher plans carry lower rates on Shopify, Squarespace and BigCommerce. Our platform guide and store planner work out what these rates cost at your sales level.

Fees on one fifty-dollar online order:

Fees on a fifty-dollar online card order (US)
PlanCard rateTotal feesYou keep
Shopify Basic2.9% + 30¢$1.75$48.25
Square Online Free3.3% + 30¢$1.95$48.05
Square Online Plus2.9% + 30¢$1.75$48.25
Wix Core2.9% + 30¢$1.75$48.25
Squarespace Core2.9% + 30¢$1.75$48.25
BigCommerce Core2.89% + 30¢$1.75$48.25
WooCommerce free plugin2.9% + 30¢$1.75$48.25
Stripe US cards2.9% + 30¢$1.75$48.25
PayPal Checkout3.49% + 49¢$2.24$47.76
PayPal Advanced card payments2.89% + 29¢$1.74$48.26

Our arithmetic from US online card rates checked November 21, 2026, using each platform's own payment processing. Before sales tax, shipping costs and any refunds or disputes.

Stripe’s rate matches WooPayments’ rate, which runs on Stripe. PayPal charges a different fixed fee on each of its card options, so the Advanced card row keeps slightly more of the order than PayPal Checkout. Both providers change their fees from time to time, so recheck before you commit.

Stripe

Stripe is a payment provider that many stores connect directly. Its US rate is 2.9% + 30¢ per domestic card payment, the same as the WooPayments rate that runs on Stripe. On top of that, international cards add 1.5% to the standard rate, and currency conversion adds 1%.

What matters for a store:

  • On Shopify in the US, you can’t add Stripe separately. Shopify’s help centre says Stripe won’t be available where Shopify Payments is supported, because Stripe is Shopify Payments’ banking partner.
  • On BigCommerce, Stripe is an embedded provider, with no BigCommerce fee.
  • On WooCommerce, Stripe works as a gateway, and WooPayments runs on it.
  • Payouts: Stripe’s default US schedule is two business days, daily, and a first payout typically takes 7 to 14 days. Instant Payouts cost 1.5% of the payout volume, with a minimum of 50¢, if you need the money sooner.
  • Disputes: $15 for each dispute received; responding costs another $15, which Stripe refunds if you win.

PayPal

PayPal’s US business fee page (headed “Last Updated: October 1, 2026” when we read it) lists:

  • PayPal Checkout: 3.49% + 49¢ per payment.
  • Advanced credit and debit card payments: 2.89% + 29¢, for cards on your own checkout.
  • Standard credit and debit card payments: 2.99% + 49¢.
  • Disputes: $15 per standard dispute ($30 for high-volume sellers), and $20 for a chargeback.

We also saw a PayPal fee sheet dated November 23, 2026, which may be a scheduled change, so check PayPal’s page for the figures in force when you sign up.

PayPal’s rate is higher than the card rates above, but shoppers who have a PayPal balance often prefer it. On Shopify, PayPal is offered through Shopify Payments and exempt from the outside-provider fee. We found no PayPal wording on payout timing to your bank, so we don’t state one.

Shopify’s outside-provider fee

Shopify allows third-party card providers such as Authorize.net, but its help centre says third-party transaction fees apply to all transactions through them, even when Shopify Payments is also active. The fee is 2% on Basic, 1% on Grow and 0.6% on Advanced, in addition to the provider’s own rate, and PayPal transactions are exempt when Shopify Payments is your primary provider. Shopify says that when you use Shopify Payments you pay the card rate and no extra transaction fee. See Shopify pricing.

BigCommerce’s embedded providers

BigCommerce lists Stripe, PayPal, Braintree, Adyen and BigCommerce Payments as embedded providers that don’t incur its open payment provider fee. Providers on its open list, such as Square, do. Our BigCommerce review explains the fee. BigCommerce Payments is powered by PayPal and open to stores in the US and UK.

Chargebacks and disputes

A chargeback, which Stripe’s documentation calls a dispute, happens when a cardholder questions a payment with their card issuer. The payment is reversed and the processor takes the amount, plus a fee, from your balance while you respond.

Platform or provider Dispute fee (US)
Shopify Payments $15 per chargeback; returned if you win
Wix Payments a chargeback costs $15 in the US, returned if you win
Squarespace Payments a payment dispute costs $20 in the US, refunded if you win
WooPayments a WooPayments dispute costs $15, refunded automatically if you win
Stripe $15 for each dispute received; responding costs another $15, which Stripe refunds if you win
PayPal $15 per standard dispute ($30 for high-volume sellers), and $20 for a chargeback
Square no fee for dispute management on chargebacks Square helps you challenge; the processing fee isn't refunded if you lose
BigCommerce Not found on the pages we could read

What to know:

  • You have limited time to respond. Square, for example, gives seven days to submit information, and the bank can take up to 90 days to decide.
  • Fees on a lost dispute aren’t returned. Square says the original processing fees aren’t refunded if you lose.
  • Cardholders have rights too. The FTC says a cardholder must send written notice of a billing error so the issuer receives it within 60 days of the first bill showing it, and the issuer must acknowledge within 30 days and resolve within 90. Federal law limits a cardholder’s liability for unauthorized charges to fifty dollars.
  • Keep records: the order, tracking, your policies and customer messages.

When the money arrives

Platform or provider Payout timing, in the vendor’s words
Shopify Payments Shopify Payments payouts typically arrive in your bank account 3 to 5 business days after a customer's payment is captured, and higher-risk accounts can wait longer
Square payments taken before 5 p.m. Pacific Time reach your bank the next business day, and next-day transfers aren't sent on Saturdays
Wix Payments payouts arrive in your bank account within 3 to 5 business days of being sent, on a daily, weekly or monthly schedule
Squarespace Payments Squarespace Payments pays out daily and funds reach US banks in 1 to 2 business days, after an 8 to 12 day hold on the first payout
WooPayments WooPayments pays out daily by default, with a pending period of 2 business days in the US and a 7-day wait before the first payout
BigCommerce Payments BigCommerce Payments, powered by PayPal, pays out in up to three business days
Stripe 2 business days by default in the US, daily; the first payout typically takes 7 to 14 days

First payouts take longer almost everywhere, because the provider verifies your identity and bank account. Plan your first week’s cash with that in mind. Timing can vary by risk level and bank; check your platform’s current help page.

Card data and PCI

If your checkout is hosted by your platform or by Stripe, you don’t handle card numbers yourself. Stripe’s guide says its Checkout and Elements host the card fields in a frame from Stripe’s own domain, so card details never touch your servers. The PCI Security Standards Council says fully hosted payment pages and frames are resistant to the theft of cardholder data, but notes that if any part of the payment page comes from your own site, the simplest self-assessment form doesn’t apply. Hosted checkout reduces your PCI obligations; it doesn’t remove them.

How to choose

If you… Use
Are on Shopify Shopify Payments, and add PayPal if shoppers ask
Are on Square Online Square; it’s the processor
Are on Wix or Squarespace Their built-in payments, plus PayPal if you want it
Must keep your own Stripe account in the US BigCommerce or WooCommerce, not Shopify
Run WooCommerce WooPayments, or Stripe or PayPal as gateways
Sell internationally Check the platform’s international card and currency conversion add-ons first

Our picks, from the rates and rules above.

Common mistakes

  • Adding an outside provider on Shopify without counting its extra fee.
  • Ignoring the first-payout hold when planning cash.
  • Not reading the dispute rules until your first chargeback.
  • Comparing headline rates only, not the fees on top, such as international cards and currency conversion.
  • Skipping PayPal, when many of your customers prefer it.

Where this fits

Payments are part of step 4 of our start-an-online-store roadmap. Our cost guide shows how card fees fit into a first-year budget, and the launch checklist includes a test order.

See Shopify

How we put this together

We read each platform’s help centre on payment processing, payouts and chargebacks, WooCommerce’s WooPayments fee page, PayPal’s US business fee page, Stripe’s payout and dispute documentation, the FTC’s guidance on disputing charges and the PCI Security Standards Council’s FAQ, and recorded each fact with a source and date in our fact log. Stripe’s US pricing page and PayPal’s fee pages change with the visitor’s country, so the figures for those two are US readings and are flagged for a recheck. This is general information, not financial advice.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a payment gateway and a payment processor?

The gateway is the checkout software that takes the card details and sends them for approval; the processor moves the money and settles it to your bank account. Many modern providers, such as Stripe, Shopify Payments and Square, do both, and sell it as one service with one rate.

Which payment gateway is cheapest for a small online store?

On the published rates the built-in processors cluster close together: about 2.9% + 30¢ per online card payment on entry plans, with Square Free higher at 3.3% + 30¢ and higher plans lower. Differences come mainly from fees on top, such as Shopify's extra fee on outside providers, so compare what each platform adds.

Can I use Stripe with Shopify?

Not in the US. Shopify's help centre says that where Shopify Payments is supported, Stripe won't be available to activate, because Stripe is Shopify Payments' banking partner. To keep your own Stripe account, BigCommerce lists it as an embedded provider with no platform fee.

Should I offer PayPal as well as cards?

Many shoppers look for it, and on Shopify, PayPal transactions are exempt from the outside-provider fee when Shopify Payments is your main provider. PayPal's own rate is higher than a card's, so it works best as an extra option.

What happens when a customer disputes a payment?

The card issuer reverses the payment and the processor takes the amount, plus a dispute fee, from your balance while you respond. Fees are about fifteen to twenty dollars on the platforms we checked, and some refund it if you win. Keep records of your order, shipping and customer messages.