Email List Building for Ecommerce: Forms, Consent and Clean Lists

Short answer: build your list with a few honest sign-up points, and collect clear consent every time. Put a sign-up form in your footer, a pop-up or flyout that appears after a visitor has seen something, and a consent checkbox at checkout; offer an incentive only if you can deliver it; and keep the list clean by removing bounces and unengaged contacts. Marketing email in the US has opt-out rules under CAN-SPAM, and text messages need written consent first. Platforms require permission-based lists anyway. This is general information, not legal advice.

On this page
  1. Why consent comes first
  2. The sign-up points that work for most stores
  3. Incentives
  4. Double opt-in and welcome flow
  5. The rules for email: CAN-SPAM
  6. The rules for text messages
  7. Keep the list clean
  8. A first month
  9. How we compared and checked

Where this comes from. The rules come from the FTC’s CAN-SPAM guide for businesses and from US federal regulation text and FCC orders on text-message consent. The forms and settings come from the help centres of Shopify, Klaviyo and Mailchimp, and Google’s guidance on pop-ups. Page updated November 22, 2026. Our priorities and order are suggestions. We haven’t built a list on any of these platforms for this guide, and we quote no sign-up rates, because we found no official ones. This is general information, not legal advice.

An email list is only as useful as the permission behind it. Shopify’s email delivery help says to make sure you have opt-in consent for all contacts, says keeping a permission-based list is required by Shopify’s Terms of Service, and says never to purchase or rent contact lists. So everything below starts with the same rule: people sign up knowingly, and you can show how.

The sign-up points that work for most stores

You don’t need all of these at once. A sensible order, our suggestion, is footer form, checkout checkbox, then a pop-up.

Where What it is Source
Footer or page section A newsletter sign-up section added to any page Shopify’s help describes adding a newsletter signup section; submitted addresses go into the Email subscribers segment
Pop-up Appears over the page Klaviyo calls popups eye-catching and high converting but potentially disruptive
Flyout A smaller panel that lets visitors keep browsing Klaviyo says visitors can keep browsing without having to interact
Full-page form Covers the window Klaviyo says it captures full attention and is more intrusive
Banner A strip across the page Klaviyo says they’re less intrusive than pop-ups and full-page forms
Embedded form Sits inside a page or section Klaviyo’s example is a footer
Checkout checkbox A marketing consent tick at checkout or sign-in Shopify lets you show it at checkout, sign-in or both

In Shopify, the Forms app offers pop-up and inline forms, and a form can show a discount code after it’s completed. Mailchimp offers an embedded form, a popup signup form, a basic hosted form and landing page forms.

Keep forms short. Klaviyo’s best practice is to keep it simple and easy to understand and fill out, and it suggests a multi-step form for list growth and compliance. For a footer form, it suggests asking for email consent only.

Pop-ups and search. Google’s page on intrusive interstitials says an overlay covering the whole page can make it hard for search engines to understand your content and suggests banners that take up only a small fraction of the screen. It exempts mandatory interstitials such as age gates. So, in our judgment, start with a small flyout or banner and show it after a delay, not on arrival.

The checkout checkbox. Shopify’s checkout settings let you choose whether the marketing consent checkbox appears at checkout, sign-in or both. It also offers a preselected option, in which customers must deselect the box to opt out; its help says the SMS checkbox can’t be preselected. Preselected boxes are a choice with consequences under the consent rules of your market, so ask an attorney before turning one on.

Incentives

Shopify’s Forms app can attach a discount code to a form to incentivize sign-ups, and says to consider offering one with a simple message. Klaviyo’s help says new subscribers will expect to use the offer right away and suggests A/B testing the offer. Our suggestion: choose something you can honor, such as free shipping or a first-order discount, state its terms next to the form, and deliver the code in the success message or the first email, as Klaviyo’s coupon help describes. Don’t promise what the sale can’t support, and read the terms of your discount before you publish it.

Double opt-in and welcome flow

Single and double opt-in, as the platforms describe them
  1. Visitor submits the formSingle opt-in: added to your audience right away (Mailchimp)
  2. Confirmation emailDouble opt-in: the person must click a link to confirm (Mailchimp, Klaviyo, Shopify)
  3. Welcome emailKlaviyo: only confirmed subscribers are queued for the welcome series

Our diagram of the platforms' descriptions. Not a screenshot.

Mailchimp defines single opt-in as adding a person immediately after they submit the form, and double opt-in as requiring them to click a link in a confirmation email. It recommends double opt-in if you aren’t focused on audience growth or have had low open rates or abuse complaints. Klaviyo says double opt-in means a new subscriber must confirm, and only those who confirm are added and queued for a welcome series. Neither says it is required for email. For abandoned-cart text messages, Mailchimp says double opt-in is required and Klaviyo says carriers often require it. We found no statement from a carrier or from CTIA, the wireless industry’s trade group, saying so: CTIA’s Messaging Principles and Best Practices (May 2023) say only that senders of recurring text campaigns should send an opt-in confirmation message before any further messages.

Shopify tracks each customer’s email subscription status as not subscribed, subscribed, pending, unsubscribed, plus invalid and redacted. Pending is the customer in the process of subscribing, which is where double opt-in lives.

The trade is simple. Double opt-in gives you a cleaner list and a record of consent; single opt-in gets you more addresses but more bad ones. Pick on that basis. Once someone is on the list, our guide to ecommerce email marketing covers the welcome and other flows, and abandoned cart emails covers recovery.

The rules for email: CAN-SPAM

The FTC’s CAN-SPAM guide for businesses lists eight points for commercial email:

  1. Don’t use false or misleading header information.
  2. Don’t use deceptive subject lines.
  3. Identify the message as an ad.
  4. Tell recipients where you are located.
  5. Tell recipients how to opt out of future marketing email from you.
  6. Remember that subscribers and members can opt out too.
  7. Honor an opt-out request within 10 business days.
  8. Monitor what others are doing on your behalf.

The guide says the opt-out explanation must be clear and conspicuous. We found no sentence on the page requiring prior permission before commercial email, which is why we lean on the platforms’ own rules above rather than saying CAN-SPAM requires opt-in. State and non-US laws can be stricter, and the guide is from August 2023, edited January 2024 for penalty amounts. Ask an attorney if you sell outside the US.

The rules for text messages

Text-message marketing is treated more strictly. We read the federal regulation, which defines prior express written consent as an agreement in writing, bearing the signature of the person called, that clearly authorizes the seller to deliver advertisements or telemarketing messages and the number to use. The signature can be electronic. The disclosure must tell the person that they authorize the messages and that they aren’t required to sign as a condition of buying anything.

Four more points from the platforms, the FCC and a court:

  • Email consent isn’t SMS consent. Shopify’s help says consent given for email marketing doesn’t apply to SMS, and that customers must opt in to SMS specifically. Klaviyo says it’s illegal to force someone to sign up for SMS to make a purchase.
  • Disclosure. Klaviyo’s sample wording includes that message frequency varies, that message and data rates may apply, how to opt out with STOP, links to your terms and privacy policy, and that consent is not a condition of purchase. That’s sample wording, not a legal list.
  • Revoking consent, from November 25, 2026. FCC rules say a person may revoke consent by any reasonable method, and the request must be honored within a reasonable time not to exceed ten business days. FCC order 26-67 (adopted September 30, 2026, released October 1) changes how that works. Law-firm alerts from Brownstein Hyatt Farber Schreck and Faegre Drinker date its effect to November 25, 2026; the order itself says 30 days after Federal Register publication, and we couldn’t read the Federal Register notice. As the order and those alerts describe it:
    • For informational calls and texts, a caller may treat a revocation as applying only to the category of message it was made in, so the “revoke-all” requirement is dropped for them.
    • For telemarketing and other marketing messages, one revocation still covers all future marketing messages from that caller.
    • A caller may designate exclusive opt-out methods, such as a key press on a call, a reply to a text with a standard word, or a website or phone number it names, if it clearly and conspicuously discloses them on the call or in the text. The standard reply words are stop, quit, end, revoke, opt out, cancel and unsubscribe, and a sender that accepts reply opt-outs must honor all of them. We couldn’t tell from what we read whether designated methods apply to marketing texts the same way, so ask an attorney.
    • The ten-business-day limit is unchanged. The FCC is only seeking comment on shortening it.
  • No “one-to-one” consent rule. The FCC’s 2023 rule that would have required each consent to name a single seller never took effect. The US Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit vacated it on January 24, 2025 in Insurance Marketing Coalition v. FCC, before its scheduled effective date of January 27, 2025.

This is general information, not legal advice. Rules on text marketing change, so ask an attorney before you launch.

We don’t give state-by-state SMS rules.

Keep the list clean

A smaller engaged list usually beats a big stale one, and the platforms give you the tools:

  • Bounces. Klaviyo automatically suppresses any address that hard bounces. Mailchimp’s cleaned contacts are those that hard bounced or repeatedly soft bounced and can’t receive future emails. Shopify says addresses that consistently bounce can’t be emailed through Shopify Messaging.
  • Unsubscribes. Klaviyo says an unsubscribed person is suppressed for all future marketing emails regardless of the list. Shopify removes subscribers when they click Unsubscribe.
  • Unengaged contacts. Klaviyo describes a sunset flow to phase out customers who are no longer engaging; suppressed profiles can’t receive marketing emails. Mailchimp says to try a re-engagement campaign before archiving contacts, and archived contacts don’t count toward your contact total.
  • Note on SMS. Klaviyo says email suppression doesn’t suppress SMS or push notifications, so handle each channel’s opt-outs separately.

Shopify’s help also says to regularly clean your subscriber list to maintain an engaged audience. Review it on a schedule, and see the email tools compared for which plans bill by contacts. Retention work such as post-purchase emails only works with a clean list.

A first month

Our suggestion, not a tested plan:

  1. Week 1: add a footer sign-up and turn on the checkout consent checkbox with clear wording.
  2. Week 2: write a welcome email and, if you offer an incentive, set up its delivery.
  3. Week 3: add a small flyout or banner on your most visited page.
  4. Week 4: check bounces and unsubscribes, and write down where each address came from.

We’d measure what happens, not assume. We make no claims about how many sign-ups any step brings.

How we compared and checked

We read the FTC’s CAN-SPAM guide, the federal regulation on telemarketing consent, FCC order 26-67 and two law-firm alerts on it, the Eleventh Circuit’s opinion in Insurance Marketing Coalition v. FCC, CTIA’s Messaging Principles and Best Practices, Google’s guidance on intrusive interstitials, and the help centres of Shopify, Klaviyo and Mailchimp on November 22, 2026. The FCC’s consumer guides would not load for our reader, so those points rest on the regulation and orders. We haven’t run these platforms’ forms ourselves. If anything here is out of date, tell us and we’ll correct it.

Frequently asked questions

How do I get email subscribers for my online store?

Use the sign-up options your platform gives you: a form in the footer, a pop-up or flyout, a newsletter section on any page, and a marketing consent checkbox at checkout. Tell people what they'll get and how often, and offer an incentive such as a discount only if you can honor it right away.

Do I need double opt-in for email?

Neither Klaviyo nor Mailchimp says double opt-in is required for email; both make it optional, and Mailchimp recommends it if you aren't focused on audience growth or have had low open rates or abuse complaints. For SMS, Klaviyo says carriers often require it, particularly for abandoned cart messages, and Mailchimp says it is required for abandoned cart texts.

Does CAN-SPAM require permission to email people?

The FTC's CAN-SPAM guide for businesses lists what you must do: no false or misleading headers or subject lines, identify the message as an ad, tell recipients where you are located, give a clear way to opt out and honor opt-outs within 10 business days. We found no sentence on that page requiring prior permission for commercial email. Your platform's terms may require it anyway: Shopify's help says keeping a permission-based list is required by its Terms of Service.

Can I text customers who gave me their email?

No. Shopify's help says consent for email marketing doesn't apply to SMS, and customers need to opt in to SMS specifically. Federal rules on automated marketing texts require prior express written consent, which we explain below.

Do pop-ups hurt my Google rankings?

Google's page on intrusive interstitials says dialogs and interstitials that obstruct content make it hard for search engines to understand your content, and suggests small banners instead of full-page overlays. It exempts mandatory interstitials, such as an age gate. We make no claims about how a particular pop-up affects your rankings.