Etsy vs Shopify (2026): Fees, Rules and Which to Start On
Short answer: start on Etsy if you make, design or digitally create what you sell and want shoppers to find you without a website of your own. Choose Shopify if you want your own brand, your own customer list and room to sell more than handmade or designed items. Etsy has no monthly fee, but it takes a cut of every sale, and an order that comes from one of its Offsite Ads costs more again. Shopify charges a monthly plan and a card fee, and brings you no shoppers. Many sellers do both, in that order. All prices here are US pricing.
Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you buy through one, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. How this works.
On this page
Best for makers, designers and digital sellers testing an idea
Etsy
No monthly fee, and Etsy's own search brings shoppers who are already looking for handmade, vintage and designed items. You pay for that on every sale: $0.20 per listing, renewed every four months and charged again for each extra quantity sold, 6.5% of each order, including shipping and payment processing.
Best for a brand you own and want to grow
Shopify
Your own store, domain and customer list, with over 16,000 apps to add later and one catalog that sells on Facebook, Instagram, YouTube and TikTok and on Amazon, Walmart and eBay. Basic, $39 a month, or $29 a month paid yearly.
Visit ShopifyShopify runs an affiliate program and may pay us if you sign up through our links. Etsy does not pay us. The picks follow the fees and rules below, not who pays us.
| Feature | Etsy | Shopify |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly fee | None. $10 a month for the optional Etsy Plus | Basic, $39 a month, or $29 a month paid yearly for the first plan |
| One-time setup fee | A one-time, non-refundable fee for opening a shop, shown during setup. Etsy says the cost varies by location and publishes no fixed amount | None stated |
| Listing fee | $0.20 per listing, renewed every four months and charged again for each extra quantity sold | None stated |
| Cut of each sale | 6.5% of each order, including shipping | None from Shopify when you use Shopify Payments |
| Payment processing (US) | 3% + 25¢ | 2.9% + 30¢ on Basic |
| Ad fee on orders from ads | Offsite Ads: 15% of an order that comes from one of its ads, or 12% once a shop passes $10,000 a year, never more than $100 an order | None. Ads you buy yourself are paid to the ad platform |
| Who finds you | Etsy shoppers, through Etsy's search | You bring them: search, ads, email, social |
| What you may sell | Made, designed, vintage or craft supplies, under Etsy's rules | Your own store; Shopify's terms and the law apply |
| Sales tax | Etsy calculates, collects and remits US sales tax for you | Shopify Tax on every plan, free up to $100,000 in lifetime global sales |
| Customer list | Etsy's rules limit how you may use buyers' details for marketing | Yours, with the consent rules that apply to any store |
| Try it | Visit Shopify |
Where this comes from. These are US prices, checked on November 20, 2026. Etsy’s fees come from its US help centre. Etsy’s own legal pages would not load for our reader, so its fee policy, creativity standards and seller policy are not quoted directly; the points that depend on them are marked below. Shopify’s plan prices and card rates were read on its US pricing page by a reviewer working with us. We have not opened an Etsy shop or a Shopify store for this comparison.
What each costs at three sales levels
Etsy has no monthly fee, so its cost is all fees on sales. Shopify has a plan price plus a card fee. This table shows what you pay in total each month at three sales levels, with an average order of fifty dollars. The Shopify column uses its cheapest plan at each level, on yearly billing.
| Sales a month | Etsy | Shopify |
|---|---|---|
| $1,00020 orders | $104standard shop: $0 plan + $104 fees | $64Basic: $29 plan + $35 fees |
| $5,000100 orders | $520standard shop: $0 plan + $520 fees | $204Basic: $29 plan + $175 fees |
| $25,000500 orders | $2,600standard shop: $0 plan + $2,600 fees | $904Basic: $29 plan + $875 fees |
Our arithmetic from US prices and online card rates checked November 20, 2026: plan price plus card fees, using each platform's own payment processing. The plan figure is the per-month price of a yearly plan, paid 12 months up front. Not included: apps, themes, a domain, shipping and sales tax.
How we worked it out: it is our arithmetic from the fee data, not a quote from either company. For Etsy we add the listing fee once to every order, which is the worst case when each sale is a new listing or a re-listing. Items that sell several times from one listing cost less in listing fees. For Shopify we add the plan price to the card fee. Neither column includes Etsy’s one-time shop setup fee (see the note below), Etsy’s Offsite Ads fee, Etsy Plus, apps, themes, shipping or your own advertising.
What the table shows:
- At small sales, Etsy is cheaper, because there is no plan to pay for.
- As sales grow, the lines cross. Etsy’s cut grows with every sale; Shopify’s plan price does not.
- The crossing point moves with your average order. A shop with many small orders pays the fixed parts of Etsy’s fees more often.
Etsy also charges a one-time setup fee when you open a shop, which is not in the table because it is a single payment, not a monthly cost. Etsy’s help says you will be charged a one-time, non-refundable fee for opening your shop, that the fee, if applicable, is displayed and charged during the shop setup process, and that the cost varies by location. Etsy publishes no fixed amount in its help, so we give none. Look at the figure Etsy shows you before you confirm.
Not in the table: Etsy’s Offsite Ads fee, which is 15% of an order that comes from one of its ads, or 12% once a shop passes $10,000 a year, never more than $100 an order, charged on top when an order comes from one of those ads. The fee page says smaller shops can opt out; larger ones cannot.
Here is one fifty-dollar order side by side:
| Plan | Card rate | Platform fee | Total fees | You keep |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Etsy standard shop | 3% + 25¢ | 6.5% + 20¢ ($3.45) | $5.20 | $44.80 |
| Shopify Basic | 2.9% + 30¢ | None | $1.75 | $48.25 |
Our arithmetic from US online card rates checked November 20, 2026, using each platform's own payment processing. Before sales tax, shipping costs and any refunds or disputes.
The fees on Etsy, one by one
All US figures, from Etsy’s help centre:
- Listing fee: $0.20 per listing, renewed every four months and charged again for each extra quantity sold. Etsy says a listing expires after 4 months and that the fee applies whether or not the item sells.
- Transaction fee: 6.5% of each order, including shipping. It applies to the item price along with shipping and gift wrap if you charge for them.
- Payment processing: 3% + 25¢ for a US bank account. Etsy says it is taken from the item’s total sale price, including shipping and any sales tax.
- Currency conversion: Etsy says a 2.5% fee applies when currency conversion is required.
- Offsite Ads: 15% of an order that comes from one of its ads, or 12% once a shop passes $10,000 a year, never more than $100 an order. Etsy says a shop that has never made the higher threshold in any consecutive 365 days can opt out.
- Etsy Plus: $10 a month, optional. Etsy lists a monthly allowance of listing credits and Etsy Ads credit, restock request alerts, expanded shop customization and unlimited Marketplace Insights searches.
When your money arrives: payout schedules can be daily, weekly, biweekly or monthly, and Etsy says new sellers default to weekly, every Monday. It also says new sellers generally have funds eligible for deposit 14 days after a sale, and that established shops may have orders available as soon as the next business day. A payment account reserve may also hold back part of the sales from new sellers of physical items; Etsy says for most sellers the reserve is removed within 90 days.
What you can sell on Etsy
This is where Etsy and Shopify differ most. Etsy limits what you can list; Shopify, being your own store, does not limit you to a type of product, though its terms and the law still apply.
From Etsy’s help centre on what you can sell:
- Made by you: physical items that you, the seller, make.
- Designed by you: Etsy says digital items must be made or designed by you, and that you can offer your original design as a digital download.
- Handpicked: this includes vintage items that are at least 20 years old.
- Craft supplies: items that enable buyer creativity, such as craft supplies and party decorations.
- Production partners: Etsy says sellers using production assistance must say so on the listing. It lists print on demand as one kind of partner, naming Printful, Printify and Gooten as examples.
We could not read Etsy’s full creativity standards, because its legal pages returned an error for our reader. Treat the list above as the outline and read Etsy’s current policy before you build a product range on it. In our judgment, general dropshipping of other brands’ goods does not fit those categories.
Who finds your products
On Etsy, shoppers come to Etsy and search. Etsy’s help says search results are ordered by how relevant the items are to what shoppers search for, and its Stats pages show how much of your shop’s traffic came through Etsy search and other Etsy pages. We quote no figures on how much traffic that brings, because we found no official ones.
On Shopify, nobody arrives by default. You bring shoppers through search, ads, email, social media and links. Our guides on ecommerce SEO and ecommerce marketing cover how. The trade is real: Etsy gives you shoppers in return for a cut of each sale; Shopify gives you control in return for the work of finding them yourself.
Customers, brand and data
On Shopify the customer list is yours, and email marketing follows the ordinary consent rules; see how to build an email list for an online store. On Etsy, buyers are Etsy’s members. Etsy’s rules, which we could not read directly, are reported to limit using buyers’ contact details to Etsy-related communication unless the buyer gives consent. Read Etsy’s seller policy before you email anyone who bought from your shop.
Branding follows the same line. An Etsy shop has a shop page inside Etsy’s design. A Shopify store has your domain, your theme and your checkout. For a brand you hope to grow, owning the address and the list matters more over time.
Sales tax
Etsy’s help says it automatically calculates, collects and remits US sales tax on behalf of sellers, for orders that meet its criteria. Shopify Tax works out US sales tax on every plan and, per Shopify’s pricing data, is free up to $100,000 in lifetime global sales, then charges 0.35% of each order on Basic, Grow and Advanced (0.25% on Plus) where Shopify works out the tax, capped at $0.99 an order. Shopify’s pricing help also says stores created before May 13, 2026 have the $100,000 threshold reset each calendar year until December 31, 2026, and it becomes a lifetime threshold from January 1, 2027. On your own store you still register with the states where you must collect. See sales tax for online stores.
Using both
Many sellers run an Etsy shop to be found and a Shopify store to own the customer. The practical limits:
- Shopify’s connector does not take new Etsy connections. Shopify’s help says new connections to Etsy can’t be made with Shopify Marketplace Connect at this time, though stores already connected can keep using it. The connector’s current marketplaces are Amazon, eBay, Walmart and Target Plus.
- Etsy documents no Shopify integration. Its help only says you can connect your Etsy shop to third-party apps, and that using an app may be subject to fees.
- Third-party apps exist. Shopify’s own app page for the connector lists other developers’ Etsy apps. We haven’t tested any, so we can’t tell you how well they sync stock.
So the realistic plan is two shops that you keep up to date, or an app you test yourself, with your inventory tracked in one place.
Moving from Etsy to Shopify
Shopify’s help describes a first-party Store Migration app. You download your Etsy listings file, upload it unedited, and the products arrive as drafts for you to review. Listings with 101 or more variation combinations import without variants. Customers, orders and reviews are only covered through third-party apps. Plan to review every imported product and its photos.
Who should pick which
Do you make, design or digitally create what you sell?
YesEtsy to start. It fits Etsy's rules and its shoppers. Add Shopify later if you want your own brand.
No? Keep going.
Do you resell other brands' goods or dropship generic products?
YesShopify. It doesn't fit Etsy's categories. Check Etsy's current rules, then build your own store.
No? Keep going.
Do you want your own customer list, brand and domain from day one?
YesShopify. You'll pay a plan price and do your own marketing.
No? Keep going.
Are you testing whether people want a product, with little cash to spend?
YesEtsy. No monthly fee, so a slow month costs little.
No? Keep going.
None of these?
List a few items on Etsy and open a trial of Shopify, then compare what each costs you and brings you after a few months.
Don’t choose Etsy if your products don’t fit its categories, or you need a checkout and brand that are entirely your own.
Don’t choose Shopify first if you have no way yet to bring shoppers to a store, and you would be paying a plan for an empty site.
These are our judgments from the documented fees and rules above. Our broader comparison of platforms is the best ecommerce platforms, and our free platforms guide shows fees on a twenty-dollar download as well.
See Shopify plans · See how Etsy fees work
How we compared them
Etsy’s fees, payout rules and seller categories come from pages in Etsy’s US help centre, read on November 20, 2026. Etsy’s own legal pages (fees policy, creativity standards, seller policy) returned an error for our reader, so anything that depends on them is marked as unconfirmed. Shopify’s prices come from our data file, which stores each figure with a source and date. The cost table is our arithmetic. We have not run a shop on either platform, so nothing here judges how easy either is to use. If a figure here no longer matches the platform’s page, tell us and we’ll correct it.
See what this costs at your own sales: try the store planner
Frequently asked questions
Is Etsy or Shopify better for a beginner?
Etsy is quicker to start if you make, design or digitally create what you sell: there is no monthly fee and shoppers can find you through Etsy's search. Shopify asks more of you, because you build the store and bring the traffic, and gives you more control in return.
Is Etsy cheaper than Shopify?
At very low sales, yes, because Etsy has no monthly fee. As sales grow, Etsy's cut of every order adds up while Shopify's plan price stays fixed. The cost tables on this page show where the lines cross. Etsy's figures: $0.20 per listing, renewed every four months and charged again for each extra quantity sold, 6.5% of each order, including shipping and 3% + 25¢ in the US. US pricing, checked November 20, 2026.
Can I sell on both Etsy and Shopify?
Yes, as separate shops. Shopify's own help says new connections to Etsy can't be made with its Marketplace Connect app at this time, and Etsy's help documents no Shopify integration. Third-party apps exist, and Etsy says using an app may be subject to fees. We haven't tested any.
Can I sell dropshipped items on Etsy?
Etsy's help says items made by a seller must be made by you, digital items must be made or designed by you, and sellers using production assistance, which includes print on demand, must disclose it on the listing. Read Etsy's current rules before you plan a product range around it.
Can I move my Etsy listings to Shopify?
Shopify's help describes a first-party Store Migration app that imports an Etsy listings file. Imported products arrive as drafts, and listings with 101 or more variation combinations import without their variants.