Ecommerce Loyalty Programs: Types, Apps and How to Start

Short answer: a loyalty program rewards customers for repeat purchases, with points, tiers, referrals or a paid membership, but it costs margin and time, so a small store should get the basics of delivery, follow-up email and service right first. If you want to start, begin with the simplest version your platform allows, such as store credit or a discount code for returning customers, then move to a loyalty app if it works. Several apps have free plans, usually capped by monthly orders, with tiers and points expiry on paid plans. We found no official source that says what a program earns a store, so we make no such claim; work out your own margin before you promise a reward.

On this page
  1. The four kinds of program
  2. Should you start one?
  3. The margin maths (ours)
  4. Start with what your platform has
  5. Loyalty apps
  6. A simple first version (ours)
  7. The rules to know
  8. Mistakes to avoid
  9. Where this fits
  10. How we put this together

Where this comes from. App plans and limits come from each vendor’s own pricing and help pages. Platform features come from Shopify’s, Wix’s, Squarespace’s and WooCommerce’s help pages. Legal points come from the FTC and the California Attorney General. Smile’s pricing page states its prices are in US dollars. LoyaltyLion’s, Yotpo’s and Rivo’s prices are the US figures from each vendor’s pricing page, read for us by a reviewer in the US; Shopify’s App Store listings showed our reader rupees, so we don’t use them for prices. The margin example and the start-small plan are our suggestions. We haven’t run a loyalty program, and we quote no figures on what one earns. This is general information, not legal or financial advice.

The four kinds of program

Type How it works Vendor’s description
Points Customers earn points for orders and actions, and redeem them for rewards Smile: earning rules decide how customers earn points, for example per dollar spent on an order
VIP tiers Customers move up levels Smile: customers enter tiers based on the points they earn or how much they spend. Wix: a levels-based program that assigns members to a tier
Referrals Customers share a link with friends Smile: the friend gets a reward on their first order, and the customer earns a reward once that order is placed
Paid membership Customers pay for ongoing perks Rivo: customized membership products with recurring monthly or annual billing

You can combine them, but a first program should be one of them. Points suit stores whose customers buy again and again; referrals suit products people recommend; tiers suit stores with enough repeat customers to fill levels; paid membership suits stores with a regular, valuable perk such as free shipping.

Should you start one?

Questions to ask:

  • Do customers already reorder? Use the repeat customer rate from our retention guide. If almost nobody reorders, find out why before adding rewards.
  • Can you afford the reward? Work out what a sale leaves you after the product, shipping and card fees, then what a reward costs out of that. Our cost guide and payment guide help with the numbers.
  • Do you have time to run it? Someone has to answer questions, fix mistakes and watch for abuse.
  • Is something simpler enough? A discount code or store credit for returning customers may do the job.

The margin maths (ours)

A made-up example, to show the method. Say a store’s order leaves it 20 dollars after product, shipping and card fees. It gives one point per dollar spent, and 100 points can be redeemed for a five-dollar reward. A customer who spends 100 dollars earns 100 points, worth five dollars. If they redeem, the store pays five dollars out of the 20 it earned on that order, leaving 15. The figures are ours and illustrative; yours will differ. The point is to check that the reward comes out of margin you can afford, including on orders that are discounted already.

Start with what your platform has

Platform What its help documents
Shopify Store credit, which you can show as a payment method at checkout and issue from a customer’s profile; you can set expiration dates, and Shopify says to verify the laws for store credit expiration dates in your country first; customers use it only when signed in through customer accounts. Gift cards. Subscriptions: auto-billed plans that renew weekly, monthly or yearly. We found no Shopify help page on loyalty programs or paid memberships
Wix A Wix Loyalty Program you can set up for free, though you must upgrade to a plan that accepts payments to launch it; points are only awarded once an order is paid; tiers need a Business or Business Elite plan in the Editor
Squarespace No built-in loyalty feature found; gift cards never expire; subscription products are available on its Basic, Core, Plus, Advanced or Commerce Advanced plans, with customer accounts enabled
WooCommerce A Points and Rewards extension, which rewards customers for purchases and other actions with points redeemable for discounts, with optional expiry
BigCommerce We couldn’t read BigCommerce’s help pages, so we state nothing

Loyalty apps

Shopify’s App Store collection of loyalty apps names, among others, BON, Joy, Smile, Growave and Rivo, each with a free plan available. Details from each vendor’s own pages:

App Free or entry plan What’s on paid plans Platforms the vendor lists
Smile.io Free plan: up to 200 orders a month, with a points program and referrals Essential $15 a month for 500 orders; Standard $79 for 1,000; Growth $199 for 2,500, with VIP tiers, points expiration and redeeming at checkout. Growth: $20 per 100 additional orders Smile's pricing page says it is available on Shopify and BigCommerce; Wix's help documents a Smile app that needs a Premium plan, a connected domain and Wix Stores
LoyaltyLion Says it recommends its free plan to stores processing 400 orders or fewer a month; referrals are on all plans Classic $199 a month, with 500 orders a month. VIP tiers are an optional add-on on Classic and included on Advanced and Plus; Advanced and Plus are priced by custom quote Shopify only, per the vendor
Yotpo Loyalty and Referrals A free plan with a basic points campaign and referrals; the order limit isn't stated Pro, from $199 a month, includes the first 500 orders; after that it charges $0.20 an order for orders 501 to 1,000, $0.10 for 1,001 to 3,000 and $0.05 for 3,001 to 10,000. VIP tiers appear on its Premium plan; billing is monthly only Shopify, BigCommerce, Adobe Commerce, Salesforce Commerce Cloud and WooCommerce, among others; not Wix or Squarespace
Rivo Its Shopify listing says free forever for up to 200 orders a month with a points program Scale from $49 a month for 200 to 2,500 orders (its page also shows a range up to $499); Plus $499 a month for up to 2,500 orders; both billed month to month. A Custom plan exists; its price isn't published. VIP tiers, points expiry and referrals are on Scale, per its listing Shopify only, per the vendor

All prices are per month, month to month. Where a vendor’s pricing page and its Shopify listing differ, the table follows the vendor’s pricing page; Yotpo’s page doesn’t state its free plan’s order limit.

What the vendor pages don’t say: we found no member limits on any plan and no statement on branding removal for Smile, LoyaltyLion or Yotpo.

A worked example: Yotpo Pro at 800 orders a month (ours)

Arithmetic only, to show how per-order pricing builds up. Yotpo Pro starts at $199 a month and includes the first 500 orders. At 800 orders in a month, 300 orders fall in the 501 to 1,000 band, which Yotpo prices at twenty cents each: 300 times twenty cents is sixty dollars. Added to the starting price, the month comes to 259 dollars. At 1,000 orders it would be 199 plus 100, or 299 dollars; the next band, 1,001 to 3,000 orders, is priced at ten cents each. The 800 is a number we chose, not a typical store.

A simple first version (ours)

  1. Pick one reward that costs you little: a small store credit or discount on a second order.
  2. Tell customers in the order confirmation and the thank-you email.
  3. Use a segment of returning customers for a special message; see our retention guide.
  4. Track it: how many redeemed and what those orders earned after the reward.
  5. Upgrade to an app only if people use it and you want points or tiers.

The rules to know

These are general US points, and we are not lawyers.

  • Disclose the terms clearly. The FTC’s guide on the word “free” says all the terms and conditions for receiving and keeping a free item should be set forth clearly and conspicuously at the outset of the offer. Spell out what customers earn, what they can redeem, any expiry and any exclusions.
  • Emails to members must follow CAN-SPAM: identify the message as an ad, include your valid physical postal address, explain how to opt out and honor opt-out requests within 10 business days, per the FTC’s guide.
  • Don’t tie rewards to positive reviews. The FTC says you can’t condition an incentive on a review being positive.
  • California. The California Attorney General’s office announced a sweep of businesses operating loyalty programs in California in 2022 and said businesses offering financial incentives must provide a notice of financial incentive under the state’s privacy law. If you have California customers, ask an attorney.
  • Expiry. We found no official US source stating what a program’s terms must say about points expiring. Shopify says to verify local law before setting store credit expiry. Ask an attorney before you set an expiry.
  • Paid memberships and subscriptions involve recurring charges, which carry their own rules; see our retention guide for what we found.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Launching rewards before delivery and service work.
  • Giving a reward your margin can’t afford.
  • Complicated rules customers can’t follow.
  • Setting expiry without checking the law.
  • Choosing by app price alone, and missing what’s locked to higher plans.
  • Not measuring whether members actually reorder.

Where this fits

Loyalty is one part of keeping customers; our retention guide covers the rest, and our CRM guide covers the data behind it. For email to members, see our email marketing guide.

Subscriptions are another way to bring buyers back: selling subscriptions online covers the platform tools and rules.

How we put this together

We read Smile’s, LoyaltyLion’s, Yotpo’s and Rivo’s pricing and help pages, Shopify’s help on store credit, gift cards and subscriptions, Wix’s help on its loyalty program and tiers, Squarespace’s and WooCommerce’s help, the FTC’s guides on the word “free”, CAN-SPAM and its reviews rule Q&A, and the California Attorney General’s press release, and recorded each fact with a source and date in our fact log. We haven’t run a loyalty program. This is general information, not legal or financial advice.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a loyalty program?

Not at first. Work on delivery, follow-up email and service before you add rewards, because a reward doesn't fix a bad first order. If customers already reorder and you want to thank them, a small program can help; our retention guide shows how to measure whether they do.

What's the cheapest way to start a loyalty program?

Use what your platform already has. Shopify's help describes store credit, which customers can use as a payment method at checkout when signed in. A discount code sent to repeat customers is another. Move to an app when you need points, tiers or referrals.

Are there free loyalty apps?

Several apps have free plans with a monthly order cap: Smile's free plan covers up to 200 orders a month with points and referrals, and LoyaltyLion says it recommends its free plan to stores processing 400 orders or fewer a month. Tiers, points expiry and some redemption options are usually on paid plans.

Can points expire?

Apps and platforms offer expiry as a setting, but we found no official US source that says what program terms must state about it. Shopify's help says to verify the laws for store credit expiration dates in your country before setting them. Ask an attorney.

Can I give rewards for reviews?

The FTC says you can't condition an incentive, such as a discount, on a review being positive. Its reviews rule doesn't prohibit incentives as long as there's no express or implied requirement for a particular sentiment.