Selling Subscriptions Online: Models, Platform Tools and Limits

Short answer: to sell subscriptions you need three things: a platform feature or app that bills on a schedule, a payment provider that supports recurring payments, and honest disclosure of what the customer agrees to. Shopify has a first-party Subscriptions app, Squarespace and Wix have subscription products with limits, and WooCommerce uses a paid extension. Each platform's rules differ on which payment providers work, whether digital products can be subscribed, and how failed payments are handled. In the US, the Restore Online Shoppers' Confidence Act still applies to online subscriptions. This is general information, not legal advice.

On this page
  1. What counts as a subscription
  2. Platform tools and limits
  3. When payments fail
  4. The rules: ROSCA and the 2025 court decision
  5. A cautious way to start
  6. How we checked

Where this comes from. The platform details come from each platform’s own help centre. Page updated November 22, 2026. The legal points come from the FTC’s Negative Option Rule page, the Restore Online Shoppers’ Confidence Act on Cornell’s legal site and a law-firm alert on the 2025 court decision. Stripe’s documentation supplies the payment-failure terms. The models and the order are our suggestions. We haven’t launched a subscription on any of these platforms, and we quote no churn or revenue statistics. WooCommerce’s price for its Subscriptions extension isn’t quoted here, because we couldn’t read it in US dollars.

What counts as a subscription

Stripe’s documentation says subscriptions let customers make recurring payments to access a product or service. For a store, the useful way to split the field, our grouping and not an official classification, is by what the customer gets:

  • Replenishment: the same item on a schedule, such as coffee or pet food. The customer expects it to keep arriving until they stop it.
  • Curated box: a changing selection each period, where you choose the contents.
  • Membership or access: pay for ongoing access, discounts or content rather than a parcel.
  • Service plans: care or maintenance on a schedule.

The model decides what your platform must do. Replenishment needs pause, skip and change-of-address tools for the customer. A box needs inventory planning. Access plans may involve digital content, which some platforms won’t let you subscribe. Start with the simplest, one product on one interval, before you design a box.

Platform tools and limits

Each platform’s help describes its own tool. Here is what we found, with the limits that matter.

Platform Tool Payment providers Notable limits, per its help
Shopify Shopify Subscriptions app, first-party Shopify Payments, PayPal Express, Authorize.net, Adyen. Stripe isn’t available as a Shopify payment gateway in the US Online store, POS, Shop and custom storefront channels; bundles aren’t compatible
Squarespace Subscription products Squarespace Payments or Stripe Not PayPal, Apple Pay or ACH; no subscription downloads; weekly to once every twelve months
Wix Subscriptions in Wix Stores A provider that supports recurring payments Up to 6 subscription options per product; none for digital products
BigCommerce An app or gateway, or its Payments API Gateways that support stored payment instruments App or payment gateway required; the Payments API route needs a Growth plan or higher
Square Online Square Subscriptions Square Pickup can’t be offered on subscription plans; a plan’s price can’t change after creation
WooCommerce The paid WooCommerce Subscriptions extension Over 25 gateways, per WooCommerce Annual extension; price not quoted here

Shopify

Shopify’s help describes the Shopify Subscriptions app as a way to build and manage subscriptions without leaving the admin, with auto-billed plans that renew weekly, monthly or yearly and various frequencies and discount types. It supports Shopify Payments, PayPal Express, Authorize.net and Adyen, and gateway availability depends on region. Stripe is listed on Shopify’s page as available only to select merchants, but Stripe isn’t available as a Shopify payment gateway in the US, as our payment gateways guide explains. Subscription products are supported on the online store, Shopify POS, Shop and custom storefront channels.

Customers can resume, skip or cancel, and manage their payment methods and shipping address, after signing in to their customer account; Shopify says a password isn’t required and sign-in uses an email and a code. Billing stops immediately on cancel, and Shopify says canceling can’t be undone. Shopify’s help also says discounts apply only to the first payment by default, gift cards used to pay for a subscription apply only to the first payment, and bundles aren’t compatible with the app. We found no Shopify plan requirement for the app and no separate fee on the help pages; the app listing shows Free with no currency, so read the listing yourself.

Squarespace

Squarespace’s help says subscription products are available on its Basic, Core, Plus, Advanced and Commerce Advanced plans, among others listed on the page, need customer accounts to be enabled, and can only be bought with Squarespace Payments or Stripe, not PayPal, Apple Pay or ACH. Subscriptions can renew as often as once a week and as infrequently as once every twelve months. The limits are real: customers can buy only one subscription product at a time, can’t use gift cards for them, you can’t create subscription download products, and you can’t place test orders until you upgrade to a paid plan. Squarespace says you can’t view a total count of active subscriptions, and customers can’t skip renewals, though you can delay the next renewal.

Wix

Wix’s help says that to sell product subscriptions you must connect a payment method that supports recurring payments. A product can be subscription-only or sold alongside one-time purchases, with up to 6 subscription options per product, none for digital products and no free subscriptions. Customers can cancel, update their payment details and, if you turn on skipping, skip upcoming orders; Wix says you can allow up to 10 skipped cycles and can’t change the billing schedule. Wix’s help names no Wix plan requirement for Stores subscriptions, but says some providers restrict recurring payments to cards.

BigCommerce

BigCommerce’s help says an app or specific payment gateway is required to add recurring billing, there are several apps in its marketplace, and gateways that support stored payment instruments can be used through its Payments API. The developer documentation says that route needs the store to be on a Growth plan or higher, to use Optimized One-Page Checkout and to have stored credit cards or PayPal accounts enabled. We could not read BigCommerce’s PayPal page, so we make no claim about PayPal.

Square Online

Square’s help says you can make items subscribable and sell them on your Square Online site, either only as a subscription or alongside one-time purchases, and toggle on pausing. It says there are no monthly fees or fixed costs for Square Subscriptions, and lists no transaction fee on that page. Limits: pickup can’t be offered on subscription plans; custom billing dates are limited to new monthly plans; and you can’t change a plan’s price after creation, swap items on active subscriptions or set commitment periods.

WooCommerce

WooCommerce’s documentation calls WooCommerce Subscriptions a premium extension that lets you sell products and services with recurring payments, with weekly, monthly and annual billing, a 30-day money-back guarantee and integration with over 25 payment gateways. Its page showed our browser a non-US currency, so we don’t quote its price; the owner’s reviewer reads it on the US page. WooPayments is compatible with it, and says only card payments and express checkout methods can be used for automatic subscription renewals.

When payments fail

Failed renewals are the quiet leak in a subscription business. Stripe’s documentation says a failed renewal payment makes the subscription past_due, and that Stripe continues to generate invoices and try payment according to your retry settings; it offers Smart Retries, which uses AI to choose the best times to retry, and describes them as a way to reduce involuntary churn. Our plain-words definitions: voluntary churn is a customer who chooses to cancel, and involuntary churn is a subscription lost because a payment failed. Stripe uses the second word without defining it.

What your platform does:

  • Squarespace: it retries after five days and a final time five days after that, and cancels the subscription if the final try fails. The customer must buy again to restart.
  • Shopify: you can adjust the number of retries and the days between them, and choose to skip, pause or cancel when all retries fail; notifications go to the customer in each case.
  • Wix: you can set a grace period that can never be longer than one full subscription cycle; if it expires without payment, the subscription cancels. Grace periods don’t apply to the first payment.

Shopify’s subscription analytics count active and canceled contracts, but don’t use the word churn. We’d watch cancellations and failed payments separately, because they have different fixes. We give no benchmark rates.

The rules: ROSCA and the 2025 court decision

Recurring charges carry legal rules, and the picture changed in 2025.

  • The FTC’s “click-to-cancel” amendments are no longer in force. The US Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit vacated the FTC’s amended Negative Option Rule, often called the Click-to-Cancel Rule, on July 8, 2025, as law-firm alerts such as Greenberg Traurig’s report. The FTC’s own March 2026 notice seeking comment refers to “the vacated 2024 Rule”, and its Negative Option Rule page lists a 2026 notice and a later request for comment on what to do next. We found no replacement rule in force.
  • The Restore Online Shoppers’ Confidence Act (ROSCA) still applies. Under 15 U.S.C. § 8403, a seller charging for an online sale through a negative option feature, such as a subscription that renews unless the customer cancels, must do three things: clearly and conspicuously disclose all material terms of the transaction before getting the customer’s billing information, get the customer’s express informed consent before charging them, and provide a simple mechanism for the customer to stop recurring charges.

We aren’t lawyers. In practice that means disclose the price, the billing interval and how to cancel plainly before you take payment, make cancelling as easy as signing up, keep a record of the customer’s consent, and ask an attorney before launching a subscription. Our customer retention guide repeats these sources, and loyalty programs covers rewards that sit alongside a subscription.

A cautious way to start

Our suggestion, not a tested plan:

  1. Pick one product and one interval, and write the disclosure first: what it costs, when it bills, how to cancel.
  2. Choose the platform tool and payment provider that match, using the table above, and place a test order if your plan allows it.
  3. Set your retry or grace settings and the customer emails before you open sales.
  4. Track cancellations and failed payments separately for the first months.
  5. Add a second interval or a box only when the first runs without trouble.

Tax on recurring orders follows the same state rules as any order; see sales tax for online stores. Payment providers are compared in our payment gateways guide.

How we checked

We read the help centres of Shopify, Squarespace, Wix, BigCommerce and Square, WooCommerce’s documentation, Stripe’s billing documentation, the FTC’s Negative Option Rule page and the text of ROSCA on November 22, 2026. BigCommerce’s PayPal page and the FTC’s 2021 policy statement PDF would not load for our reader. We haven’t run a subscription business, so nothing here describes how any tool performs. If something here is out of date, tell us and we’ll correct it.

Frequently asked questions

What do I need to sell subscriptions on my store?

A platform feature or app that creates recurring orders, a payment provider that supports recurring payments, and a way for customers to see, pause or cancel their subscriptions. Platforms differ: Shopify's app needs one of its supported payment gateways, Squarespace needs Squarespace Payments or Stripe, and Wix needs a payment method that supports recurring payments.

Can I sell a subscription to digital products?

It depends. Wix's help says product subscriptions cannot be created for digital products, and Squarespace says you can't create subscription download products. Shopify's help lists no such rule for its app. Check your platform's current help before you plan a digital subscription.

What happens when a subscription payment fails?

It depends on the platform and provider. Squarespace says it tries again after five days and a final time five days later, then cancels the subscription. Shopify lets you set the number of retries and days between them, and choose to skip, pause or cancel when they run out. Wix lets you set a grace period that can't be longer than one full subscription cycle.

Is the FTC's click-to-cancel rule in force?

No. A federal appeals court vacated the FTC's amended Negative Option Rule in July 2025, and we found no replacement rule in force. ROSCA still applies to online subscriptions, so disclose the terms before taking billing information, get express consent and make stopping simple. Ask an attorney.

How do I reduce subscription cancellations?

Fix what you can control: collect payment details that renew reliably, retry failed payments, make pause and skip options available if your platform has them, and send clear reminders. We quote no churn statistics, because none we found came from an official source.