BigCommerce vs Shopify (2026): Which Is Better for a Small Store?

Short answer: for most small stores, Shopify is the better buy on published terms. Both cost the same to start, but BigCommerce moves you to a dearer plan automatically as your yearly sales grow, while Shopify lets you choose. BigCommerce's clear advantage is card processing through Stripe: it charges no platform fee on Stripe and its other embedded providers, where Shopify adds 2%, 1% or 0.6% on any card processor other than Shopify Payments. PayPal alone isn't the difference: a Shopify store using Shopify Payments can also offer PayPal without Shopify's extra fee. If you need Stripe as your card processor, that can outweigh everything else. All prices here are US pricing.

Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you buy through one, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. How this works.

On this page
  1. What each costs at three sales levels
  2. The sales thresholds
  3. Payment providers: BigCommerce’s real advantage
  4. Features
  5. Feature by feature
  6. Who should not choose each
  7. If you switch later
  8. Which should you choose?
  9. How we compared them

Best for most small stores

Shopify

You choose when to upgrade, abandoned cart emails and B2B features are on every plan, and its app store lists over 16,000 apps. Basic, $39 a month, or $29 a month paid yearly.

Visit Shopify

Best for taking card payments through Stripe instead of Shopify Payments, with no platform fee

BigCommerce

Stripe, PayPal, Braintree, Adyen and BigCommerce Payments are among its embedded payment providers, so orders through them carry no BigCommerce fee. PayPal alone isn't the difference: a Shopify store using Shopify Payments can also offer PayPal without Shopify's extra fee. Budget for automatic upgrades: Core covers online sales up to $30K a year.

Visit BigCommerce

Shopify runs an affiliate program and may pay us if you sign up through our link. BigCommerce gets a plain link. The picks follow the prices, fees and plan terms below, not who pays us.

BigCommerce vs Shopify (2026): Which Is Better for a Small Store?
FeatureShopifyBigCommerce
Entry plan (US)Basic, $39 a month, or $29 a month paid yearlyCore, $39 a month, or $29 a month paid yearly
Who decides when you upgradeYou doBigCommerce, once yearly sales pass your plan's threshold
Online card rate, own payments2.9% + 30¢ / 2.7% + 30¢ / 2.5% + 30¢2.89% + 30¢ / 2.59% + 30¢ / 2.39% + 30¢
Fee with Stripe as card processor2% / 1% / 0.6% by planNone: an embedded provider
Fee on PayPal ordersNone when Shopify Payments is your main providerNone: an embedded provider
Fee with other outside providers2% / 1% / 0.6% by plan2% / 1% / 0.6% by plan, for providers on its open list such as Square
Abandoned cart emailsAll plansFrom the Growth plan
Variants of one product2,048 variants per product600 variants per product
Selling to businessesB2B features on every planCustomer groups from Growth; price lists on Performance
Free trial3 days free, then $1 a month for 3 months.15-day free trial, no card needed.
Try it Visit Shopify Visit BigCommerce

Where this comes from. These are US prices, checked on November 20, 2026. BigCommerce’s card rates, payment-provider lists, thresholds and upgrade rule come from its help centre, read directly; its pricing page blocks automated readers, so the plan prices and the open provider fee rates were also read on the US page by a reviewer working with us. Shopify’s prices and rates were read on its US pricing page by the same reviewer and checked against a second source. We have not built a store on either platform.

What each costs at three sales levels

The cheapest plan each store can use at three levels of online sales, with an average order of fifty dollars and each platform’s own payment processing. BigCommerce’s plan is set by its yearly sales thresholds.

What you pay each month, on yearly billing
Sales a monthShopifyBigCommerce
$1,00020 orders$64Basic: $29 plan + $35 fees$63.90Core: $29 plan + $34.90 fees
$5,000100 orders$204Basic: $29 plan + $175 fees$238.50Growth: $79 plan + $159.50 fees
$25,000500 orders$904Basic: $29 plan + $875 fees$1,046.50Scale: $299 plan + $747.50 fees

Our arithmetic from US prices and online card rates checked November 20, 2026: plan price plus card fees, using each platform's own payment processing. The plan figure is the per-month price of a yearly plan, paid 12 months up front. BigCommerce's rates are BigCommerce Payments' US rates for each plan. Not included: apps, themes, a domain, shipping and sales tax.

What you pay each month, on month-to-month billing
Sales a monthShopifyBigCommerce
$1,00020 orders$74Basic: $39 plan + $35 fees$73.90Core: $39 plan + $34.90 fees
$5,000100 orders$214Basic: $39 plan + $175 fees$264.50Growth: $105 plan + $159.50 fees
$25,000500 orders$914Basic: $39 plan + $875 fees$1,146.50Scale: $399 plan + $747.50 fees

Our arithmetic from US prices and online card rates checked November 20, 2026: plan price plus card fees, using each platform's own payment processing. BigCommerce's rates are BigCommerce Payments' US rates for each plan. Not included: apps, themes, a domain, shipping and sales tax.

What the tables show:

  • At the lowest level they cost the same. Both entry plans share a price, and BigCommerce’s card rate is a hair lower.
  • From the middle level, BigCommerce costs more. Selling five thousand dollars a month is sixty thousand a year, past Core’s $30K a year, so BigCommerce moves the store to Growth. The Shopify store stays on Basic.
  • BigCommerce’s falling card rate doesn’t close the gap. Its rate drops to 2.39% + 30¢ on Scale, but the plan price rises faster. BigCommerce’s pricing page states “begins at 2.89% + $0.29”; we use the per-plan rates from its help centre.

The sales thresholds

Each BigCommerce plan covers a band of yearly online sales:

Plan A month Paid yearly Covers online sales up to
Core $39 $29 $30K a year
Growth $105 $79 $100K a year
Scale $399 $299 about $400K a year, then 0.9% above
Performance From $1,499 By quote Custom

BigCommerce’s help centre explains the rule: it totals your order value over the last 12 months, takes off 10%, and when that passes your plan’s threshold, it upgrades you from the next billing cycle. Shopify has no such rule: you move up when a higher plan’s lower card rate or extra staff accounts are worth it, which on fees alone is above about twenty-five thousand dollars a month on yearly billing.

Read more: BigCommerce vs Wix vs Squarespace, which explains the thresholds in full

Payment providers: BigCommerce’s real advantage

This is where the two differ most, and it matters if you already use a particular payment processor.

Shopify wants you on Shopify Payments. Use any other provider, such as Stripe, as your card processor and Shopify adds its own fee: 2% on Basic, 1% on Grow, 0.6% on Advanced. On five thousand dollars a month of sales on Basic, 2% is a hundred dollars a month. PayPal is the exception: Shopify’s help centre says PayPal transactions carry no extra fee when Shopify Payments is your primary provider. So PayPal alone isn’t the difference; Stripe is.

BigCommerce charges no platform fee on orders through its embedded payment providers. Its help centre lists Stripe, PayPal, Braintree, Adyen and BigCommerce Payments are among its embedded payment providers. Providers on its open list, such as Square, Authorize.net and Clover, carry its open provider fee: 2% on Core, 1% on Growth, 0.6% on Scale. So does a set of other orders, including offline payments, marketplace orders and orders from point-of-sale apps.

Does payment choice decide it for you?
  1. Are you happy to use the platform's own card processing?

    YesShopify, for most stores. Shopify Payments has no extra fee, and Shopify costs less as you grow.

    No? Keep going.

  2. Do you need Stripe as your main card processor instead of Shopify Payments, for example because your business already runs on it?

    YesBigCommerce. No platform fee on Stripe, where Shopify would add 2% on Basic.

    No? Keep going.

  3. Do you need Square for online card payments?

    YesEither charges a fee. Square is on BigCommerce's open list, and Shopify charges its fee on any outside provider.

    No? Keep going.

  4. None of these?

    If you have no preference, Shopify Payments on Shopify is the simplest and, on published terms, the cheapest route.

Features

Catalog. Shopify allows Unlimited products on all plans and 2,048 variants per product. BigCommerce allows 600 variants per product, with no store-wide product limit on its limits page. BigCommerce tracks stock in 4 inventory locations on Core, 5 on Growth and 8 on Scale.

Selling to businesses. Shopify’s help centre says its B2B features (company accounts, payment terms, quantity rules and price breaks) are on every plan from Basic, with up to three active catalog assignments below Plus. On BigCommerce, customer groups start on Growth, price lists need the Performance plan, and its B2B Edition is an enterprise product sold through its sales team.

Abandoned carts. Shopify includes recovery emails on all plans; BigCommerce from From the Growth plan.

Apps. Shopify’s app store lists over 16,000 apps.

Trials and offers. Shopify offers 3 days free, then $1 a month for 3 months. BigCommerce offers a 15-day free trial, no card needed. It was also running a promotion when we checked: 50% off the first year of a yearly Core, Growth or Scale plan for new customers, through December 31, 2026.

Feature by feature

Feature Shopify BigCommerce
Store editor Theme editor with sections and blocks, plus the Sidekick AI assistant Page Builder: drag-and-drop widgets on a Stencil theme
Free designs 24 free themes in the Theme Store Free and paid themes; Cornerstone is free on every store; no count published
Editing theme code In the theme code editor On a copy of the theme, in the browser or with its command-line tool
Checkout One page by default Optimized One-Page Checkout by default
Express checkout Shop Pay, Apple Pay, Google Pay, PayPal, Amazon Pay Apple Pay, Google Pay, PayPal and Venmo; Amazon Pay through Stripe
Pay in installments (US) Shop Pay Installments, with Shopify Payments PayPal Pay Later
Shipping labels (US) Built in: USPS, UPS, DHL and FedEx Through apps such as ShipStation, Shippo and Easyship
Sales tax Shopify Tax on every plan, free up to $100,000 in lifetime sales Avalara AvaTax at a fixed rate tied to your plan, or Vertex, TaxJar or TaxCloud
Product addresses /products/ is a fixed path; the end is editable You choose the pattern: /product-name by default
Redirects Built in, up to 100,000 Created automatically when an address changes, plus a redirect manager
robots.txt Editable through a theme file Editable in the store settings
Blog Basic plan includes a blog Built in, basic, with tags
Selling in person Shopify POS: some features on every paid plan; POS Pro is an add-on Connects to Square, Clover, Lightspeed, PayPal Zettle or Teamwork
Languages up to 20 languages on Basic, Grow and Advanced up to 5 languages per storefront; plans not stated
Several currencies at checkout With Shopify Payments With a Stencil theme, its one-page checkout and a gateway that supports it
Support 24/7 chat on every plan; phone and email only on Plus 24/7 chat and email on every plan; phone on Core is a paid add-on

From Shopify’s help centre and product pages and BigCommerce’s help centre, read on November 20, 2026. “Not stated” or “no count published” means the pages we read didn’t say.

Setup and the store editor

Both are hosted. Shopify’s setup checklists put settings, payments, shipping and taxes first, then the theme, which you edit in sections and blocks beside a live preview; its AI assistant, Sidekick, works from any page of the admin. A new BigCommerce store starts in a private pre-launch state with a checklist on its dashboard and a “Launch my store” button. Its Page Builder lets you drag widgets into set regions of a page, as long as the store uses one of its Stencil themes.

Themes and design

Shopify’s Theme Store filter shows 24 free themes, with paid themes sold as a one-time purchase. BigCommerce’s marketplace has free and paid themes, and Cornerstone is free on every store; BigCommerce doesn’t publish a count in its help centre. Both let you edit theme code. On BigCommerce you work on a copy of the theme, and the browser editor can’t change JavaScript files, which need its command-line tool.

Checkout and express payments

Both default to a one-page checkout. Shopify lists Shop Pay, Apple Pay, Google Pay, Amazon Pay and PayPal as accelerated checkouts, and US merchants offer PayPal through Shopify Payments; Shop Pay Installments lets US customers split orders from $35 to $30,000.

BigCommerce supports Apple Pay and Google Pay through several gateways, including its own payments, Stripe and PayPal. PayPal buttons can go on product, cart and checkout pages, with PayPal Pay Later for US stores and Venmo for shoppers in the US. Amazon Pay runs through Stripe. On this, the two are close.

Shipping

This is a clear Shopify advantage. Shopify Shipping sells USPS, UPS, DHL and FedEx labels inside the admin. Shopify’s US shipping page advertises up to 88% off USPS, and its help centre says discounts vary by plan.

BigCommerce’s built-in USPS labels, through Endicia, are no longer available to new stores, according to its help centre. New stores buy labels through partner apps such as ShipStation, Shippo, Easyship and DesktopShipper, each with its own pricing. Live rates at checkout from FedEx, UPS and others need your own carrier accounts, and BigCommerce integrates with ShipperHQ for more complex rules.

Sales tax

Shopify Tax is open to every plan, works out US sales tax from the buyer’s address and flags states where you are nearing a threshold. It is free up to $100,000 in lifetime sales, then charges 0.35% of each order where Shopify works out the tax, capped at $0.99 an order.

BigCommerce integrates with Avalara, Vertex, TaxJar and TaxCloud. Signing up for Avalara AvaTax through BigCommerce costs a fixed rate tied to your store’s plan; the help centre doesn’t give the figure. Neither platform files your returns by default.

SEO controls

This is BigCommerce’s strongest feature area. Under Settings, then URL Structure, you choose how product addresses look: just the product name (/product-name, the default it recommends), with /products/ in front, with the category, or a custom pattern. It creates redirects automatically when a product’s name or address changes, and its redirect manager imports and exports lists. Its robots.txt can be edited in the store settings.

Shopify calls /products and /collections “fixed Shopify paths”, so every product sits under /products/. It has a redirect manager for up to 100,000 addresses, and its robots.txt can be edited only through a theme file it calls an unsupported customization. Both generate sitemaps automatically. If clean addresses matter to you, read our site structure guide first.

Blogging

Both have a built-in blog. Shopify’s Basic plan includes one, with tags rather than categories. BigCommerce describes its own blog as basic: tags, a search description and a single blog shared across all storefronts. For a store that plans to publish regularly, see our comparison of store blogs.

Selling in person

Shopify has its own point of sale: its help centre says all paid plans include some in-person selling features through the Shopify POS app, with a card reader, and Tap to Pay on iPhone in the US. POS Pro is a paid add-on for each location. BigCommerce has no point of sale of its own. It connects to Square, Clover, Lightspeed, PayPal Zettle and Teamwork to sync stock and orders. Remember that BigCommerce’s open provider fee also applies to orders from point-of-sale apps.

Languages and currencies

Shopify sells in up to 20 languages on Basic, Grow and Advanced, and its free Translate & Adapt app can translate up to 8 languages automatically for US stores; selling in several currencies needs Shopify Payments. BigCommerce allows up to 5 languages per storefront, though its help centre doesn’t say which plans include multiple languages. It supports several transactional currencies with a Stencil theme, its one-page checkout and a gateway that supports them, which its help centre says includes Stripe, PayPal and BigCommerce Payments.

Customer support

BigCommerce’s help centre says all plans include 24/7 live chat and email support, and phone support on Core is a paid add-on at $29 a month. Shopify offers 24/7 chat on every plan, with phone and email only on Plus and Retail plans. For a small store wanting email support, BigCommerce gives more.

Who should not choose each

Don’t choose Shopify if:

  • Your business must keep Stripe as its main card processor. Shopify’s extra fee on outside card processors can cost more than any other difference here.

Don’t choose BigCommerce if:

  • You are starting out and expect steady growth. Its yearly thresholds move you up a plan whether or not you need the extra features.
  • You want abandoned cart emails on the entry plan. BigCommerce includes them from Growth.
  • You want to sell wholesale on a small budget. Shopify’s B2B features start on Basic; BigCommerce’s customer groups start on Growth and its price lists on Performance.
  • Your main payment processor is Square. It is on BigCommerce’s open list, so its orders carry BigCommerce’s fee.

These are our judgments from the documented features and costs above.

If you switch later

Neither choice is permanent. Products, customers and orders can be exported from one platform and imported into another, often with a migration app; the design has to be rebuilt. Three things make a move painless:

  • Own your domain from the start, so your address stays the same.
  • Redirect every old address to its new one, so search traffic and links follow. Our site structure guide covers how.
  • Keep your customer list and email tool separate from the platform where you can, so marketing carries on during the move.

Which should you choose?

  • Most small stores: Shopify Basic. Same starting price, no forced upgrades, and the larger app store.
  • You need Stripe as your card processor instead of Shopify Payments: BigCommerce, with Growth in your budget if your sales are steady.
  • You sell wholesale to other businesses on a small budget: Shopify, whose B2B features start on Basic.
  • You expect to sell more than about thirty thousand dollars a year from the start: price BigCommerce at Growth, not Core, before you compare.

For a three-way look with Wix, see Wix vs BigCommerce vs Shopify. For all our platform picks, see the best ecommerce platforms for small business.

See Shopify plans · See BigCommerce

How we compared them

Prices, card rates, fees, thresholds and limits are stored in our data file with a source and date. BigCommerce’s payment-provider lists, card rates by plan and upgrade rule were read directly in its help centre; its open provider fee rates and plan prices also come from the reviewer’s read of its US pricing page, because the page blocks our reader. The cost tables are our arithmetic, using each platform’s own payments and, for BigCommerce, the plan its thresholds require. We have not built a store on either platform. If a price here no longer matches the platform’s page, tell us and we’ll correct it.

Frequently asked questions

Is BigCommerce better than Shopify?

For most small stores, no: on published terms Shopify costs the same to start and less as sales grow, because BigCommerce upgrades your plan automatically past each yearly sales threshold. BigCommerce is better if you want to process card payments through Stripe instead of Shopify Payments, because it charges no platform fee on Stripe, where Shopify adds 2% on Basic. PayPal alone isn't the difference: a Shopify store using Shopify Payments can also offer PayPal without Shopify's extra fee.

Which is cheaper, BigCommerce or Shopify?

At low sales they cost the same: $29 a month paid yearly for either entry plan. As sales grow BigCommerce moves you to Growth at $79 a month once yearly online sales pass $30K a year, while a Shopify store can stay on Basic. US pricing, checked November 20, 2026.

Does BigCommerce charge transaction fees?

Not with its embedded payment providers, which include BigCommerce Payments, Stripe and PayPal. Orders through providers on its open list, such as Square, and some other orders (offline payments, marketplace and point-of-sale app orders) carry its open provider fee: 2% on Core, 1% on Growth and 0.6% on Scale.

Does Shopify charge a fee if I use PayPal or Stripe?

On Stripe, yes: Shopify adds 2% on Basic, 1% on Grow and 0.6% on Advanced on orders through any card processor other than Shopify Payments. On PayPal, not if Shopify Payments is your primary provider: Shopify's help centre says PayPal transactions are then exempt. So PayPal alone isn't a reason to choose BigCommerce.

Can I move from BigCommerce to Shopify?

Yes. Products, customers and orders can be exported and imported, often with a migration app. The design has to be rebuilt. Set up redirects from old addresses so search traffic follows.