How the store planner decides
This page is printed from the same rules file the store planner runs on, so the two can't disagree. The planner works in three passes: stop rules add a warning or end the plan, route rules choose the platform, and the cost pass chooses the plan on that platform. Affiliate links never feed into any rule; the rules file has no place for them, and our build fails if one is added.
The questions
- Where is your business based? Prices, fees and rules on this site are for the US.
- What will you sell? It decides which platforms fit at all.
- How much do you expect to sell online in a typical month during your first year? Card fees grow with sales, and some plans only pay off at higher sales.
- How many products will you sell? Some free plans cap the number of products.
- Will you also sell in person? (optional) Some platforms share one item list between your website and a card reader.
- Do you already have a website? Adding a store to the site you have usually beats moving.
- How comfortable are you with the technical side? (optional) Self-hosted stores cost less but leave updates and security to you.
- What's your monthly budget for the platform itself? Free plans exist, with limits.
- Do you need any of these? (tick any) (optional) A must-have can rule a platform or a plan out.
- Have you sold this product before, anywhere? (optional) If not, testing demand first is cheaper than building a store.
Sales bands become a working figure for the costs: Under $500 → $300; $500 to $2,000 → $1,000; $2,000 to $5,000 → $3,000; $5,000 to $25,000 → $10,000; Over $25,000 → $25,000; I don't know yet → $1,000. You can type an exact figure instead. Orders are sales divided by a typical order of $50, which you can change on the result.
Stop rules
Checked first. Some add a message above the plan; "Choose a product first" ends the plan.
Choose a product first
When: Sells: Not sure yet.
What you see: A platform is the easy part. Pick what you'll sell, check people want it and that it leaves a margin, then come back. The plan ends here.
Don't build a store yet
When: Sold before: No, I'm testing an idea; Budget: As little as possible: free is fine; Sells: Physical products I make or Print-on-demand designs or Digital downloads (ebooks, templates, music, courses).
What you see: Test demand first. Etsy has no monthly fee and accepts items you make or design, including print-on-demand made by a disclosed production partner. Or open a store on a free plan. The plan below is for when you're ready.
Sources
- Etsy pricing data (etsy.standard)
- Etsy pricing data (etsy.addons.listing)
- Etsy: What Can I Sell on Etsy?
- Etsy's Creativity Standards
- /best-free-ecommerce-platforms
Test before you pay for a store
When: Sold before: No, I'm testing an idea; Budget: As little as possible: free is fine; Sells: Physical products I buy in to resell.
What you see: Square Online's free plan takes payments with no monthly fee, so you can test demand before paying for anything. Etsy isn't an option for resold products: its Creativity Standards require items to be made, designed, handpicked or sourced by the seller.
Sources
- Square Online pricing data (square.free)
- Etsy: What Can I Sell on Etsy?
- Etsy's Creativity Standards
- /setup-store-on-square
Work the margin first
When: Sells: Dropshipped products; Sold before: No, I'm testing an idea.
What you see: With dropshipping, advertising usually decides whether a sale makes money. In our worked example on a forty-dollar sale, twelve dollars of ads per sale leaves $6.54; twenty dollars of ads turns it into a loss. Run your own numbers before you pick a product.
There's no free plan for dropshipping apps
When: Sells: Dropshipped products; Budget: As little as possible: free is fine.
What you see: The dropshipping apps Shopify recommends run on a paid Shopify store. The cheapest real start is Shopify's trial: 3 days free, then $1 a month for 3 months.
Sources
- Shopify pricing data (shopify.freeTrial)
- Shopify's recommended dropshipping apps (/dropshipping fact log)
Route rules: choosing the platform
The first rule that matches your answers wins. Must-haves come first: your own Stripe account, then wholesale, then languages or currencies. If no plan on the chosen platform meets your must-haves, the next rule is tried.
Services or bookings
When: Sells: Services or bookings.
We suggest: Wix. Runner-up: Squarespace.
Why: Wix is a website builder first, with selling built in. We haven't compared booking tools yet. These are website builders that can also sell, not a bookings recommendation.
Sources
- Wix pricing data (wix.core)
- Squarespace pricing data (squarespace.core)
- /best-website-builders
Must-have: your own Stripe account
When: must-have: My own Stripe account as card processor.
We suggest: BigCommerce. Runner-up: WooCommerce if Tech: I'm happy to manage hosting, plugins and updates; otherwise Squarespace.
Why: Stripe is one of BigCommerce's embedded payment providers, so its orders carry no BigCommerce fee. Budget for automatic upgrades: BigCommerce moves you to a higher plan as yearly sales pass each threshold.
Sources
- BigCommerce pricing data (bigcommerce.claims.embedded)
- BigCommerce pricing data (bigcommerce.claims.upgradeRule)
- Shopify: payment gateway availability (/bigcommerce-vs-shopify fact log)
- Squarespace payment methods (/squarespace-vs-shopify fact log)
- /shopify-vs-woocommerce
Must-have: selling wholesale (B2B)
When: must-have: Selling wholesale to other businesses (B2B).
We suggest: Shopify. Runner-up: WooCommerce if Tech: I'm happy to manage hosting, plugins and updates; otherwise BigCommerce.
Why: Shopify's help centre lists company accounts, payment terms, quantity rules and price breaks on every plan from Basic, with up to 3 active catalog assignments below Plus.
Sources
- shopify.claims.b2b
- BigCommerce pricing data (bigcommerce.claims.customerGroups)
- BigCommerce pricing data (bigcommerce.claims.priceLists)
- WooCommerce pricing data (woocommerce.addons.extensions)
- /shopify-vs-wix fact log (SparkLayer)
Must-have: several languages or currencies
When: must-have: Several languages or Several currencies at checkout.
We suggest: Shopify. Runner-up: Wix.
Why: Shopify sells in up to 20 languages on Basic, Grow and Advanced, and selling in several currencies works with Shopify Payments.
Sources
- Shopify pricing data (shopify.claims.languages)
- Wix pricing data (wix.claims.languages)
- /shopify-vs-wix feature table
Already on WordPress
When: Website: Yes, on WordPress.
We suggest: WooCommerce. Runner-up: Shopify.
Why: The store joins the site you already run, on hosting you already pay for. There's no platform fee on sales.
Sources
- WooCommerce pricing data (woocommerce.plugin)
- /shopify-vs-woocommerce
Already on Wix
When: Website: Yes, on Wix.
We suggest: Wix. Runner-up: Shopify.
Why: The store joins the Wix site you already have. Selling starts on the Core plan.
Sources
- Wix pricing data (wix.core)
- /shopify-vs-wix
Already on Squarespace
When: Website: Yes, on Squarespace.
We suggest: Squarespace. Runner-up: Shopify.
Why: The store joins the Squarespace site you already have.
Sources
- Squarespace pricing data (squarespace.core)
- Squarespace pricing data (squarespace.basic.transactionFee)
- /squarespace-vs-shopify
Already on Shopify
When: Website: Yes, on Shopify.
We suggest: Shopify. Runner-up: Squarespace.
Why: You're already on Shopify: the question is which plan, and the cost pass below answers it.
Sources
- Shopify pricing data (shopify.basic)
- /squarespace-vs-shopify
Digital downloads
When: Sells: Digital downloads (ebooks, templates, music, courses).
We suggest: Payhip. Runner-up: Gumroad.
Why: The lowest share of any free option we compare. Payhip says it "automatically collects, reports and remits digital EU/UK VAT as well as US/Canadian sales tax" on your behalf, as a marketplace facilitator in the US.
Sources
- Payhip pricing data (payhip.free)
- Payhip pricing data (payhip.plus)
- Payhip pricing data (payhip.pro)
- Payhip pricing data (payhip.claims.tax)
- Gumroad pricing data (gumroad.direct)
- Gumroad pricing data (gumroad.claims.mor)
- Etsy pricing data (etsy.standard)
- /best-free-ecommerce-platforms
Selling in person too, under $5,000 a month
When: In person: Sometimes, at markets or events or Yes, from a shop counter; sales under $5,000 a month.
We suggest: Square Online. Runner-up: Shopify.
Why: A free plan that takes payments. One item library for in-person sales and the website.
Sources
- Square Online pricing data (square.free)
- Square Online pricing data (square.free.inPersonRate)
- Shopify pricing data (shopify.claims.pos)
- /setup-store-on-square
1 to 5 physical products, free is fine
When: Products: 1 to 5; Budget: As little as possible: free is fine; Sells: Physical products I make or Physical products I buy in to resell.
We suggest: Big Cartel. Runner-up: Square Online.
Why: Free for up to 5 products, with payments through Stripe or PayPal. No Big Cartel transaction fee.
Sources
- Big Cartel pricing data (bigcartel.gold)
- Big Cartel pricing data (bigcartel.claims.stripeRate)
- Square Online pricing data (square.free)
- /best-free-ecommerce-platforms
More than 5 physical products, free is fine, no in-person sales
When: Products: 6 to 50 or 51 to 500 or More than 500; Budget: As little as possible: free is fine; Sells: Physical products I make or Physical products I buy in to resell; In person: No.
We suggest: Square Online. Runner-up: Shopify.
Why: A free plan that takes payments with no limit on items.
Sources
- Square Online pricing data (square.free)
- /best-free-ecommerce-platforms
Print-on-demand
When: Sells: Print-on-demand designs.
We suggest: Shopify. Runner-up: Squarespace.
Why: Shopify's help centre recommends print-on-demand apps, including Printful and Gelato.
Sources
- Shopify recommended dropshipping and POD apps (/dropshipping fact log)
- Squarespace Extensions
Dropshipping
When: Sells: Dropshipped products.
We suggest: Shopify. Runner-up: WooCommerce if Tech: I'm happy to manage hosting, plugins and updates; otherwise Wix.
Why: Shopify's help centre lists dropshipping apps that connect suppliers to your store, including Shopify Collective.
Sources
- Shopify recommended dropshipping apps (/dropshipping fact log)
- Wix Modalyst dropshipping
- Squarespace Extensions
Happy to run hosting, and a blog is a must-have
When: Tech: I'm happy to manage hosting, plugins and updates; must-have: A blog for content and search traffic.
We suggest: WooCommerce. Runner-up: Shopify.
Why: WordPress has the strongest blogging tools of any store setup. No platform fee on sales.
Sources
- WooCommerce pricing data (woocommerce.plugin)
- WooCommerce pricing data (woocommerce.addons.hosting)
- hosting.com pricing data (hostingcom.small.renewal)
- /ecommerce-blogging
Everything else: physical products
When: any answers not matched above.
We suggest: Shopify. Runner-up: Squarespace if Products: 1 to 5 or 6 to 50; must-have: A blog for content and search traffic; otherwise Wix.
Why: Room to grow: you choose when to upgrade, and apps, sales channels and B2B features are there when you need them.
Sources
- Shopify pricing data (shopify.basic)
- /best-website-builders (verdict: a store you plan to grow)
- /squarespace-vs-shopify
- /shopify-vs-wix
- /bigcommerce-vs-shopify
The cost pass: choosing the plan
- The planner costs every plan on the chosen platform at your sales and orders: the plan price, plus card fees, plus any platform fee per sale. It works this out separately for paying monthly and paying yearly, and never mixes the two.
- It picks the cheapest plan on first-year cost (paying yearly where a yearly price is published). A higher plan is picked only if it meets a must-have you ticked: your own domain, or staff logins. On an exact tie, the lower plan wins.
- BigCommerce is the exception: its plan is set by your yearly sales against its thresholds, so you can't choose it.
- WooCommerce includes hosting at hosting.com Small plan for WordPress's renewal price, $9.99 a month, unless you already have a WordPress site.
- Other platforms in the table are shown for comparison but never decide. If one is cheaper than the recommendation, the plan says so, with the reason we still suggest the recommendation.
- Prices come from our pricing data, with the date each was checked. A price more than 60 days old is marked in amber.
What the planner won't do
- Promise income, profit or success. Costs are costs; dropshippers and anyone testing an idea see the margin method or a test-first message.
- Let affiliate links change a result. Brands we have an affiliate link with and brands we don't are treated the same.
- Recommend booking software: we haven't compared it yet, and the plan says so.
Questions or a rule that looks wrong? Tell us.